Historical Fiction Annotation- The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane


Author: Lisa See
Title:  The Tea Girl of Hummingbird Lane
Genre: Historical Fiction
Publication Date: March 21, 2017
Publisher: Scribner
Number of Pages: 384
ISBN13: 9781501154829
Geographical Setting/ Time Period: Remote, rural village in a tea growing region of China
Series: Stand-alone
Subject Headings: Adopted children, Chinese American teenagers, Identity, Mothers and daughters, Akha (Southeast Asian people), Group identity

Plot Summary:

Life of Li-yan and the Akha people, who live in a remote Yunnan village, revolves around the seasons, spiritual/cultural traditions, and tea. Her family is wise in the ways of growing the finest of teas and producing the ancient art of curing and fermenting the leaves. Li-yan is extremely bright, and has the promise of an educated future, something rarely offered to those in her village. However, one day, a jeep arrives in the village carrying a stranger that seeks a rare tea. He does not only bring himself, but his tales of the world outside the small village.

Beginning to reject what she has grown up knowing, Li-yan craves a new life and begins a forbidden relationship with San-pa. Li-yan becomes pregnant, unbeknownst to San-pa, and decides to have the baby outside of wedlock, effectively severing her ties with her family. She leaves the healthy baby girl in the nearest city, in hopes that she will be adopted in America.

This novel follows the life of Li-yan over the next 20 years, as she branches out from the restrictions of her village, and yearns to find the child that she gave up. Meanwhile, her daughter Haley, although well loved and wealthy in California, yearns to know her origins and birth mother. Truly, an emotion packed story of culture, loss, tradition, and everything in between.

Appeal:

Tone/Mood: Sincere, thoughtful, sentimental, & complex

Diction: The language is beautifully crafted and enjoyable for readers to savor. No excessive language, each word feels necessary and right.

Storyline: Steeped in tradition and superstition, this storyline flows beautifully, reminding readers of the depth of the culture and the strong family ties throughout the host of characters.  My only critique is that is that the novel got slightly bogged down with excessive detail in the second half and lacked the first half’s emotional power.

Characterization: This book was filled with Ahka culture: the spirituality, the superstitions, the food, the work, the daily life, and the tea. With that culture came beautifully crafted characters that readers cannot help but invest their emotions and heart into.  Seamlessly weaving in historical facts, Lee transported me into Li-yan’s world spanning 20+ years. Li-yan is a strong character and I was sympathetic to her sorrows.  The only qualm I have with characters is the eventual shift to her daughter’s perspective, which I did not enjoy nearly as much.

Pacing: Definitely not fast-paced, more like an easy, lazy gait throughout. However, this in no way detracts from the story; rather it feels as if you glide through with something compelling you forward to keep reading.

Writing Style: Extremely immersive. Readers are taken in detail through the lives of the Akha people. Readers will be entrenched and captivated by the vivid cultural and spiritual values, even if you do not truly understand them.

Historical Fiction Characteristics:

  •          Past events into a fictional series
  •          Inclusion of historical events or people
  •          Authentic and believable details
  •          Well-researched
  •         Accurate linguistic choices
  •          Believability factors


Read-a-likes/ Similar Authors:
  • The Women in the Castle by Jessica Shattuck
  • Snow Flower and the Secret Fan by Lisa See
  •  The Shape of Water by Guillermo del Toro & Daniel Kraus


Comments

  1. Andrea,

    I think I will have to add this to my TBR list...the way you describe it makes me want to know more about the main character's choices, and how they relate to her culture. I've never read anything by Lisa See before, and I was wondering if you think this would be a good book for people new to her to start with?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I actually read her novel Snowflower and the Secret Fan first about a year ago and highly enjoyed it. It is probably her most well-known/recieved.

      Delete
  2. Andrea,

    Wow! This novel looks so good! I love historical fiction, so I feel every historical fiction book looks good. I love how you wrote the plot summary. It totally drew me in. There is so much tradition, culture, and history in this story. However, it seems that there is a lot of pain and heartache. I love novels that include a whole array of emotions. This is going on my to-read list!

    ReplyDelete
  3. I love how you described this novel, especially the pace and writing style sections. Have you read The Shape of Water already? I have a hold on it ... fingers crossed I get to read it soon!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi Andrea,
    I think it's interesting that the second half of the book was weighted down with more detail than the first half. I only say this because one element of the pacing of historical fiction (at least according to Saricks) is that the first half is usually more detail-oriented since all the facts and historical elements are usually found there in to set the back story and setting. Of course we all know there really is no 100% "formula" for any genre! And anyway - this definitely sounds like something I would read!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Excellent annotation! I've read reviews of this, but didn't think twice, but your annotation and appeals has me intrigued, I'll have to check this out! Great job! Full points!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular Posts